Skip to main content

Table 2 WAI and ITP according to the legal category of detention.

From: Working alliance, interpersonal trust and perceived coercion in mental health review hearings

 

T1

T2

T3

 

Mental Health Act 2001

Criminal Law (Insanity) Act 2006

Mental Health Act 2001

Criminal Law (Insanity) Act 2006

Mental Health Act 2001

Criminal Law (Insanity) Act 2006

Patient rates consultant psychiatrist

WAI

57.2(14.9)

60.8(15.8)

56.3(18.2)

64.7(17.5)

51.2(21.8)

64.0(15.8)

ITP

35.6(7.1)

39.4(6.9)

36.7(7.7)

39.9(8.0)

32.1(9.0)

39.4(8.7)

Patient rates primary nurse

WAI

58.1(16.7)

63.1(13.7)

56.7(19.2)

64.3(16.4)

51.6(19.9)

63.7(15.5)

ITP

36.4(6.5)

38.6(5.0)

36.3(6.9)

39.6(8.2)

33.9(7.6)

38.4(8.4)

Patient rates doctors in general

ITP

40.2(7.6)

40.1(6.8)

37.7(6.4)

41.3(8.9)

35.8(8.7)

41.4(8.6)

Consultant psychiatrist rates patient

WAI

43.7(15.7)

55.1(15.0)

43.9(18.3)

55.9(14.0)

41.5(18.2)

56.5(15.1)

ITP

22.0(8.1)

28.5(8.7)

21.2(6.3)

29.8(8.1)

19.2(7.1)

30.0(9.3

Primary nurse rates patient

WAI

51.3(10.3)

58.2(13.4)

48.7(12.2)

57.1(13.9)

48.4(14.6)

57.9(12.3)

ITP

24.8(4.1)

31.6(7.2)

26.4(5.5)

32.2(7.4)

29.9(7.8)

31.9(7.9)

  1. Note that those detained under the Mental Health Act 2001 must be reviewed by the Mental Health Tribunal (n = 17), those detained under the Criminal Law (Insanity) Act 2006 must be reviewed by the Mental Health Review Board (n = 58). T1 = six months before the next hearing, T2 = two weeks before and T3 = two weeks after the hearing. Means and standard deviations.